Top 8 Personal Injury Lawyer In Dayton

By Amanda Reyes | Published: Undated Analysis | Category: Personal Injury Lawyer

About Personal Injury Lawyer In Dayton

Personal injury lawyers represent individuals who have been physically or psychologically harmed due to the negligence or wrongdoing of another person, company, or entity. They help clients seek compensation for medical expenses, lost wages, pain and suffering, and other damages.

How We Evaluated

Providers were evaluated based on their client reviews, reported case successes, years of experience, range of personal injury services offered, and their established presence in the Dayton area.

Rating Criteria

  • Client Satisfaction
  • Experience & Reputation
  • Case Type Specialization
  • Local Presence & Accessibility
  • Resources & Firm Size

The Best Personal Injury Lawyer In Dayton

📍

Currently showing results for: Dayton

Get Directions
View Personal Injury Lawyer Near You
Gregory S. Page Co., LPA #8

Location: 10 W Monument Ave #1, Dayton, OH 45402 Get Directions

Gregory S. Page Co., LPA

Visit Website →

A Dayton-based personal injury law firm dedicated to representing victims of accidents and negligence.

Target Audience

Individuals injured in auto accidents, Victims of general negligence

Service Offerings

Auto Accidents

Handles car, truck, and motorcycle accident claims.

Wrongful Death

Provides legal assistance to families who lost a loved one.

Premises Liability

Represents clients injured on someone else's property due to unsafe conditions.

Scorecard (Overall: 7.0 / 10.0)

Case Type Specialization 7.0
Client Satisfaction 7.0
Experience & Reputation 7.0
Local Presence & Accessibility 8.0
Resources & Firm Size 6.0

Pricing Model

Contingency Fee

Legal fees are contingent upon successful recovery.

Pros

  • + Local Dayton attorney with direct client involvement
  • + Specific focus on personal injury law
  • + Accessible office location

Cons

  • - Likely a smaller practice, which may have limitations in terms of resources for extremely complex or large-scale litigation compared to larger firms.

Verdict

"A good local option for straightforward personal injury cases where clients prefer working directly with a dedicated Dayton attorney."

User Reviews

Loading reviews...

The Fitch Law Firm LLC #7

Location: Dayton, OH (Serves Dayton; primary offices elsewhere) Get Directions

The Fitch Law Firm LLC

Visit Website →

With over 30 years of experience from its lead attorney, this firm handles significant personal injury cases across Ohio, including Dayton.

Target Audience

Victims of serious accidents, Individuals with catastrophic injuries

Service Offerings

Serious Injury Claims

Focus on cases involving traumatic brain injuries, spinal cord injuries, and other severe harm.

Vehicle Accidents

Representation for car, truck, and motorcycle accident victims.

Wrongful Death

Helping families pursue claims after losing a loved one due to negligence.

Scorecard (Overall: 7.4 / 10.0)

Case Type Specialization 8.0
Client Satisfaction 8.0
Experience & Reputation 8.0
Local Presence & Accessibility 6.0
Resources & Firm Size 7.0

Pricing Model

Contingency Fee

No attorney fees unless compensation is recovered.

Pros

  • + Highly experienced lead attorney
  • + Focus on severe and catastrophic injury cases
  • + Track record of significant results

Cons

  • - Primary offices are not in Dayton, though they serve the area (may utilize meeting locations). Less direct Dayton physical presence.

Verdict

"A strong choice for high-stakes, severe injury cases, especially if the client values deep experience in such matters, despite not having a primary Dayton office."

User Reviews

Loading reviews...

O'Connor, Acciani & Levy #6

Location: 130 W 2nd St #1900, Dayton, OH 45402 Get Directions

O'Connor, Acciani & Levy

Visit Website →

A multi-state law firm with a Dayton office, offering a broad range of personal injury, workers' compensation, and social security disability services.

Target Audience

Injured individuals, Disabled workers, Those seeking Social Security benefits

Service Offerings

Auto Accidents

Representing clients injured in car, truck, and motorcycle accidents.

Workers' Compensation

Assisting employees injured on the job.

Social Security Disability

Helping individuals navigate SSDI claims.

Scorecard (Overall: 7.4 / 10.0)

Case Type Specialization 7.0
Client Satisfaction 7.0
Experience & Reputation 7.0
Local Presence & Accessibility 8.0
Resources & Firm Size 8.0

Pricing Model

Contingency Fee

No upfront costs for personal injury cases; fees are paid from the settlement or award.

Pros

  • + Multiple office locations across states
  • + Broad service range including WC and SSDI
  • + Free initial consultations

Cons

  • - Diversified practice areas may lead to less specialized focus on complex personal injury litigation compared to niche PI firms.

Verdict

"A versatile firm suitable for clients who may have overlapping personal injury, workers' comp, or SSDI needs."

User Reviews

Loading reviews...

The Attkisson Law Firm, LLC #5

Location: 130 W Second St #1620, Dayton, OH 45402 Get Directions

The Attkisson Law Firm, LLC

Visit Website →

Led by a Board Certified Civil Trial Advocate, this firm focuses on serious personal injury cases, particularly vehicular accidents and catastrophic injuries.

Target Audience

Victims of severe accidents, Those needing specialized trial advocacy

Service Offerings

Car Accidents

Handling complex car accident claims, including those with serious injuries.

Trucking Accidents

Experienced in litigation involving commercial truck collisions.

Catastrophic Injuries

Representation for life-altering injuries such as brain or spinal cord damage.

Scorecard (Overall: 7.8 / 10.0)

Case Type Specialization 8.0
Client Satisfaction 9.0
Experience & Reputation 8.0
Local Presence & Accessibility 7.0
Resources & Firm Size 7.0

Pricing Model

Contingency Fee

No fee unless successful recovery is made.

Pros

  • + Lead attorney is a Board Certified Civil Trial Advocate
  • + Focus on serious injury cases
  • + Potential for more personalized client service

Cons

  • - Smaller firm, which may mean fewer resources for handling multiple large-scale cases simultaneously compared to larger firms.

Verdict

"A strong contender for serious injury cases where specialized trial expertise and personal attention are highly valued."

User Reviews

Loading reviews...

Hochman & Plunkett Co., L.P.A. #4

Location: 20 S St Clair St, Dayton, OH 45402 Get Directions

Founded: 1969

Hochman & Plunkett Co., L.P.A.

Visit Website →

A Dayton law firm with a very long history, offering services in personal injury, medical malpractice, and other civil litigation matters.

Target Audience

Individuals injured due to negligence, Clients needing trial attorneys for civil disputes

Service Offerings

Personal Injury Litigation

Representation for various injury types, including vehicle accidents and premises liability.

  • Focus on trial preparation
Medical Malpractice

Advocacy for patients harmed by medical errors.

Wrongful Death Claims

Seeking justice and compensation for families.

Scorecard (Overall: 7.8 / 10.0)

Case Type Specialization 7.0
Client Satisfaction 8.0
Experience & Reputation 9.0
Local Presence & Accessibility 8.0
Resources & Firm Size 7.0

Pricing Model

Contingency Fee

Typically works on a contingency basis for personal injury cases.

Pros

  • + Decades of legal experience in Dayton
  • + Respected trial lawyers
  • + Established local reputation

Cons

  • - Broader practice than just personal injury, which might mean less specialization in PI compared to dedicated PI firms.
  • - Smaller firm resources compared to the largest PI firms.

Verdict

"A reputable, long-standing Dayton firm for those who value extensive trial experience, though their practice is not solely focused on personal injury."

User Reviews

Loading reviews...

Dyer, Garofalo, Mann & Schultz L.P.A. #3

Location: 4130 Linden Ave, Dayton, OH 45432 Get Directions

Founded: 1990

Dyer, Garofalo, Mann & Schultz L.P.A.

Visit Website →

Locally recognized as 'The Tiger', this firm has a long-standing presence in Dayton, handling personal injury, medical malpractice, and Social Security Disability claims.

Target Audience

Injury victims, Disabled individuals seeking benefits, Victims of professional negligence

Service Offerings

Personal Injury

Covers a broad range of injury cases including auto accidents, premises liability, and dog bites.

  • Free case evaluation
  • Contingency fee basis
Medical Malpractice

Handles claims against doctors, hospitals, and other healthcare providers for negligence.

Truck Accidents

Specialized representation for complex cases involving commercial trucks.

  • Federal trucking regulation knowledge

Scorecard (Overall: 8.2 / 10.0)

Case Type Specialization 8.0
Client Satisfaction 8.0
Experience & Reputation 8.0
Local Presence & Accessibility 9.0
Resources & Firm Size 8.0

Pricing Model

Contingency Fee

You don't pay unless they win your case.

Pros

  • + Strong local brand recognition
  • + Over 30 years of service in the Dayton area
  • + Handles a variety of related claims including SSDI

Cons

  • - Practice areas extend beyond personal injury, which may mean less singular focus than some specialized PI firms.

Verdict

"A solid, well-established local choice for various injury claims, known for their community presence and aggressive representation."

User Reviews

Loading reviews...

Elk & Elk Co., Ltd. #2

Location: 1 S Main St STE 1860, Dayton, OH 45402 Get Directions

Founded: 1995

Elk & Elk Co., Ltd.

Visit Website →

A well-known, large Ohio-based law firm with a dedicated Dayton office, specializing in serious personal injury and medical malpractice cases.

Target Audience

Victims of medical negligence, Individuals seriously injured in accidents

Service Offerings

Medical Malpractice

Significant focus on cases involving medical errors and negligence by healthcare providers.

  • Birth injuries
  • Surgical mistakes
  • Failure to diagnose
Car & Truck Accidents

Representing clients injured in serious vehicular accidents.

  • Complex liability assessment
  • Maximizing compensation
Wrongful Death

Providing legal support to families who have lost loved ones due to others' negligence.

Scorecard (Overall: 8.6 / 10.0)

Case Type Specialization 9.0
Client Satisfaction 8.0
Experience & Reputation 9.0
Local Presence & Accessibility 8.0
Resources & Firm Size 9.0

Pricing Model

Contingency Fee

No fees are charged unless they win your case. Fees are a percentage of the recovery.

Pros

  • + Highly experienced in medical malpractice
  • + Substantial firm resources for complex litigation
  • + Statewide recognition and numerous successful outcomes

Cons

  • - Due to firm size, client experience can vary; some may find it less personal than smaller firms.

Verdict

"An excellent option, particularly for medical malpractice victims and those with catastrophic injuries, given their specialized expertise and resources."

User Reviews

Loading reviews...

#1

View Top Ranked Provider

Watch a short ad to unlock the details for the #1 ranked provider.

Kisling, Nestico & Redick #1

Location: 1 W Monument Ave #501, Dayton, OH 45402 Get Directions

Founded: 2005

Kisling, Nestico & Redick

Visit Website →

A prominent Ohio personal injury firm with a strong Dayton presence, KNR handles a wide spectrum of accident and injury claims.

Target Audience

Accident victims, Injured individuals, Families seeking wrongful death compensation

Service Offerings

Motor Vehicle Accidents

Representation for victims of car, truck, and motorcycle collisions.

  • Thorough investigation
  • Aggressive negotiation with insurers
  • Trial representation
Medical Malpractice

Addressing cases of harm due to negligence by healthcare professionals.

  • Surgical errors
  • Misdiagnosis
  • Birth injuries
Wrongful Death

Assisting families in obtaining compensation for the loss of a loved one due to negligence.

  • Pursuing damages for lost support and companionship

Scorecard (Overall: 8.8 / 10.0)

Case Type Specialization 9.0
Client Satisfaction 9.0
Experience & Reputation 9.0
Local Presence & Accessibility 8.0
Resources & Firm Size 9.0

Pricing Model

Contingency Fee

Clients typically pay no upfront fees; legal fees are a percentage of the recovered amount, paid only if the case is successful.

Pros

  • + Extensive experience across Ohio
  • + Large team with significant resources
  • + Strong track record of substantial settlements and verdicts
  • + Multiple office locations

Cons

  • - As a large firm, some clients might prefer more direct, consistent contact with a single attorney throughout their case.

Verdict

"A top choice for serious and complex injury cases, benefiting from KNR's considerable resources and established reputation."

User Reviews

Loading reviews...

Amanda Reyes

Written By

Amanda Reyes

Editor-in-Chief

Final Recommendation

Dayton offers a range of skilled personal injury lawyers, from large, resource-rich firms ideal for complex litigation to smaller practices providing personalized service. Key differentiators include specific case type specializations (like medical malpractice), firm size and resources, and depth of local experience. Most operate on a contingency fee basis, making legal help accessible.

🏆 Best Overall Kisling, Nestico & Redick
💲 Best Value The Attkisson Law Firm, LLC
✨ Elk & Elk Co., Ltd. Elk & Elk Co., Ltd. is particularly strong for complex medical malpractice cases due to their extensive experience and resources in this specific domain.